|
|
Post by uptowndragon on May 13, 2007 9:54:33 GMT 7
Many people in the forum are unhappy that Sean was unceremoniously eliminated in Episode 6, as they felt that he was one of the stronger and more versatile dancers in the competition. From being at the top of the pile in Episode 5 to the bottom 4 in less than 7 days, it is a little hard to chew by most.
Even his fellow contestants seemed to be alarmed by his quick exit, as most of them seem to think that he was one of the contestants to beat.
So what happened? Why did such luminary judges who were quite aware of his qualities and praised him so wonderfully a week earlier, suddenly decide he should be exposed to the voting public so soon?
Why were people not voting enough for him to keep him alive? Perhaps Sean didn't have a chance to connect with voting public as yet, or he did not already have a fan base to help him out of trouble. Or did the fans of the other contestants perceive him as one of the biggest threats to their favourites, saw the opportunity presented, and decided to expel him quickly out of the competition. Well, it has happened before in other reality shows as Rentak Sejuta can easily testify.
If it was strategic sabotage, how do the other contestants survive their stint in the bottom 4 next. Interesting considerations, isn't it?
What do you think guys. Please share your thoughts and ideas. We definitely want to know.
|
|
|
|
Post by suemicheline on May 13, 2007 10:26:08 GMT 7
Well for Sean's elimination, i think that those that watched at home, were not voting as much as they should be. I mean, some watch the show like its just a show on tv, you know. it would not kill them if they(dancers) got out or in. However, unless they really fell connected to the participants, there would be a definite difference, or if they are really supporting SYTYCD. I was so sad, really sad to be hearing his name being called out. BUt like some say, "its all in the game.." so i hope that ppl at home do 'vote' who they want to be Malaysia's favourite dancer!
|
|
|
|
Post by vish on May 13, 2007 10:27:04 GMT 7
sean is great... vers dancer he deserved to b in the final
|
|
|
|
Post by idolfan on May 13, 2007 13:52:34 GMT 7
I dont think Sean deserved to be in the bottom 4 in the first place. Wonder why the judges did that ...praised him a week earlier then suddenly bottom this week   There were others more deserving in the bottom 4 than him ..... I think he and brancy was great together ..they seemed to click ery well in their dance performance ...what a pity  |
|
|
|
Post by felicia on May 13, 2007 15:10:56 GMT 7
i do not agree that sean shud be in da bottom as well...and of course he shudnt be eliminated out...he is reali talented and do hv the chemistry wif Brancy wen they are partnering each other for their danz...its such a waste to lost sean in da competition... jz depending 100 percent on da vote from msian is not enuf...and its nt fair as well...wat if a dancer is real good but do not reali hv much supporters like others..n msians dat r watching da show is nt connected to da participants..they jz wont vote...so i tink is not reali fair to jz base on msian's voting...i tink dat da elimination shud nt jz base on msian;s voting..but oso da judges point of view...to ensure the real capability of a msian best dancer!!!!
|
|
|
|
Post by Bong on May 13, 2007 17:07:06 GMT 7
Hmmm.. was thinking COULD THIS BE dued to the lack of time..?? as i stated that 25 minutes is definitely not enough for voting in this show.. not like in singing competition.. when one sing.. u can definitely hear at that point itself whether is he/she a "mantap" singer.. whether did that fella got out of pitching or so.. but dancing it will be harder for everyone to judge it at that point.. what more.. the judges have to judge them IMMEDIATELY..
Just like us.. i m sure the judges need time to decide who to be at the bottom 4.. but in just that short term due to the time of the show.. the judges have to bring up their bottom 4 just right after everyone perform.. that will not affect those dancers with good big fan base.. but if ppl like sean.. they are just starting to get fans.. and only at that point ppl only have 25 minutes to vote for him.. obviously those with a BIG FAN BASE will dominate and "sorry" have to be sent to sean..
Will keep myself on my stand suggesting 8tv should make the result show on the other night maybe.. allowing the judges to have more time to decide on the bottom 4 and on the second night.. let the bottom 4 perform and then audience will have more time to think who to vote for.. In My Opinion-lah.. hehehe..
|
|
|
|
Post by starccs on May 13, 2007 20:14:16 GMT 7
of coz not.. he did great with that tiara song.. he's sooo freaking good... sighs...
|
|
|
|
Post by jasonsiah on May 13, 2007 20:30:17 GMT 7
I think bottom 4 is not a place for sean.. But I do agree with BongBong.. The time for voting is just too SHORT~~ 25min?? Enough for what? My opinion will be the same.. Make it the second night for the supporters to hv more time to vote.. Then at least.. No regret as it's fair enough~
|
|
|
|
Post by annjet on May 16, 2007 16:29:48 GMT 7
sean is great... vers dancer he deserved to b in the final argh..ya man, was so surprised!!! chris's good too but din expect sean to b eliminated so early! sighz..  |
|
|
|
Post by lavender on May 16, 2007 20:33:10 GMT 7
i totally agree with you guys that sean SHOULD NOT be in the bottom 4 and deserved to be in the finals. he is a strong dancer and really click with brancy. they are the perfect match! everything seems so perfect seeing both of them dacing together. sean had better performances n i expected to see more in future. too bad that m'sia didn't stand on his side
|
|
