Did the judges pick the wrong contestants?

[uptowndragon]

Many people we met over the course of the competition, seem to feel that the judges may have picked some contestants who should have never made it to to the top 12, and are simply taking up space that could have been made available to someone much better or more deserving.

We certainly like to hear your comments and thoughts about that, on whether you guys feels the same way, or are quite happy with the current batch.

It's your forum, so let's hear what you all have to say.

[victor]

I'll TRY my best to restain of heavy complaining. But my votes is Yes. Some contestant are... a waste of slot. Most of them is out already, so I won't say anything. Also, I would like to drag the voting patern into this, until today, I still find Rony and Iz got the boot too early, instead, the ones who is not so good ended up screwing up.

[greg]

well, some of them are, but i still have faith in the judges. and who are we to judge them? they've been in showbiz for years.