|
|
Post by uptowndragon on Mar 26, 2009 23:16:26 GMT 7
In today's diary, we found Esther & Fify apologizing to songwriter Aidit Alfian. I am perturbed why these two contestants have to carry the burden of apologizing to the songwriter when they have actually done no wrong. They followed the wishes of the songwriter not to change the melody. The ones that actually insulted the songwriters on national TV were both Syafinaz & Paul. So how come they are not the ones apologizing instead. What gives?
Its very damaging to the contestants as they will be seen as the bad guys instead. Seems like they ending up as the scapegoats.
Let's hear all your thoughts guys.
|
|
|
|
Post by romiflizz on Mar 26, 2009 23:19:28 GMT 7
i dah vote yaa..
|
|
|
|
Post by norajoey on Mar 27, 2009 8:30:07 GMT 7
i think its fine for fify n esther made appologies to the songwriter..
but at the same time..the judges shld do the same thing..
becoz they(judges) are the one who sounded the songwriter for not giving the contestants freedom to change n do what they(contestants) want on that songs..
but at the first place the contestant who are the one misunderstood n didn't understand what the songwriter talk about..and from that misunderstood all the things occur...so either fify,esther,paul or syafinaz they have to make appologies to aidit...
thats just an opinion from myside..huhu
|
|
|
|
Post by geolimarkisa on Mar 27, 2009 16:38:03 GMT 7
i guess they made that apologies simply bcos they hve made the wrong assumption about aidit. .if they didnt know what melody is all about, they shud hve asked.what bothers me most was why the judges were so pissed off...it makes me wonder..is it bcos esther could not make the best of the song.?.well i dont know..i do wonder
|
|
|
|
Post by fanatix on Mar 30, 2009 13:26:27 GMT 7
personally, i think it'd be better 4 aidit 2 be a bit more open to the idea of changing the arrangement to suit the contestants' voices.
|
|
|
|
Post by mart on Apr 1, 2009 10:10:33 GMT 7
i am strongly against the contestants apologizing to aidit.
in the first place, it wasnt Fify and Esthers fault that Aidit did not want to allow changes to the song.
as ssomeone who is borrowing his song, we (8TV, OIAM, Paul and Syaf) should be more sensitive to the fact that it is his song and we cannot comment and make a mock out of him on NATIONAL TV, on him not allowing to change the melody of the song.
Somebody needs to drill come sense into Syaf's head especially. This is the wrong thing to do and i hold Paul and Syaf totally liable for whatever damages they have caused. Not the contestants. period.
|
|
|
|
Post by uptowndragon on Apr 1, 2009 10:42:04 GMT 7
Recent word has it that Aidit did not actually disallow them to change the song, he just asked them not to stray from the melody. Apparently both Fify & Esther did not understand his instructions clearly and assumed that they were not allowed to jazz up the songs, and complained to the judges of the assumed limitations, who then took the songwriters to task on TV. That's why Fify & Esther were seen apologizing to Aidit in the diaries. (Most of us would be clueless the way it was presented on diaries, unfortunately.)A press release to that effect has been uploaded at www.gua.com.my, but no matter how hard I have been trying to locate it there, I can't seem to find it. Maybe you guys will have better luck and will link the release here, so others can understand better. But that still does not absolve the judges from criticizing the songwriters on national TV. |
|
|
|
Post by geolimarkisa on Apr 1, 2009 12:15:53 GMT 7
what on earth make esther n fify to go n complain it to the judges in the first place.n to think that syafinaz had taken it a step 4ward n critisized aidit on national tv...she shud hve make a little investigation of her own or just simply asked around... i guess all of them shud apologised to aidit..n if they had already done it then lets hope it's allready over n hopefully will not happen again in future....
|
|
