YOU BE THE JUDGE! of Ning & Shafinaz's Vocals

[uptowndragon]

Ostro, you can always create a new thread for it. LOL!!! No worries.

[anita]

ok, see its like this Simon Cowell can't sing, he says he can't sing, we'll believe he can't sing. Clive Davies is an old man, don't know if he can sing but I think we can trust an astute man like him NOT to when he knows he can't.
Yes, then we have Paul Moss saying he can't sing and so he refrains from said singing.......

And then we have someone like Syafinaz???

Oh look I think I saw a cow fly over the moon!!!!!! LOL!

[rayboycharmed]

lmf said:

guys...i can't sing, yet i know wat works for a singer.
Second, have u actually heard the worlds top recording artists sing live? Rember Live8? Nuff said
Does a footbal manager have to have been a top player?
Does the mechanic have to be a racing driver?

You get my point..and as usual i've overstated it:)
Cheers

Agreed Paul.. but as the saying goes "YOU DONT HAVE TO BE A GOOD SINGER TO COMMENT ON BAD SINGING" equals to "YOU DONT HAVE TO SCREAM TO BE A GOOD SINGER" equals to "YOU DONT HAVE TO BE RUDE TO A FELLOW COLLEAGUE JUST BECOZ HE DOES NOT UNDERSTAND NOR SPEAKS BAHASA WELL"

So i guess Syafinaz knowing that she is not a good singer NEED NOT have to criticize nor be rude to prove her point that she can judge people on their singing/song choice etc..

She should be able to take criticism constructively from the viewers about herself just like she want the viewers to understand her criticism about the contestants..

Syafinaz needs to learn that it aint ONE WAY STREET for her..

It all work both ways and i guess i too, have made my point too...

Cheers!

Applause for Paul though for indirectly standing up for his fellow colleague despite the treatment he got..lol.. shows the team spirit in him.. (just like in my office ) lol ;D

[idolhunter]

Phew Ostro... ;D U never leave any unturned stones along the way...
You have raked the whole ocean floor.... for answers...
and you have also destroyed every living thing in the ocean floor...
;D ;D ;D along the way....

Well smart move by acknowledging you are a farahnatic.. becos
everyone in Malaysia knows that..

I like the way you write postings but sometimes its abit too long... ;D
.. try to make short and firm...good effort here...
and I m sure Shafinaz will get your point of view... ;D

Like I said.. OIAM - the clown judges of the show... ;D
What has happened to the good old professional jugement
so as the make the fans/ viewers proud of their idol...
and value them as worth a million Ringgit...
Come on the contestants or judges are not in clown uniform..
and the moment you make fun of each other's judgements as worthless piece of nuts.. the whole system of quality collapse
A judgement is nothing but a fulcrum between the lever and the object...
come on - Paul, Shafinaz,, both of you are the fulcrum of the whole OIAM future... and looks like both of you are shooting each other and
undermining the base/fulcrum of the whole machine...
Its about time you judges wear the judge's white hair and stand
firm in yr judgement...
Judge the contestants and not each other's right/wrong judgements.
yes.. yes a little homour doesn't hurt... but it not humour anymore...
its clear grudges.. even b4 shafinza judge.. paul is already shaking his head...and Shafinaz must end her judgement with a kick under the belt b4 passing it to him...
Both of you are pouring poison into the drink and asking us to drink it...